
We are just back from a week on the remote Maine island of Isle au Haut, a place of rocky coasts, craggy woods, and lobster boats. It was exhilarating to get away to a place of such untainted beauty and spend a week in the company of food-loving friends.
A week’s vacation is a luxury, especially for a farmer, but a great opportunity to enjoy the fruits of our labors.
Isle au Haut has a small general store but no restaurants, so we loaded the car up with veggies and staples for a week-long cooking marathon. When we got to the ferry launch seven hours later we unloaded it all, plus our luggage and children, and schlepped everything onto the passenger “mail boat” - the island’s only connection to the mainland.
What the island lacks in sumptuous farmers markets and high-end restaurants it more than makes up for in its berry-laden brambles, muddy clam flats, mushroom-filled forests and fertile lobster fishing grounds. We treated ourselves to an unforgettable week of wild Maine foods.
I mean, the first thing I want to do when I break free of the farm is to head for the shore, put on my work boots and dig for clams. This activity bears an uncanny resemblance to hand-digging potatoes, but that didn’t stop us. Digging steamers may kill your back and wreck your nails (just like farming) but the proceeds are pure profit. And so delicious!
To make the moment even more perfect, we shared this experience with our dear friend and former housemate Dinah, who, being from Maine, introduced us many years ago to the pleasure of steamer clams. Dinah has since moved to Chicago and started a pie-baking business, but she was back in her element on the sulfurous sands.
When it comes to deliciousness, never judge a book by its cover. There may not be anything as tasty in the entire world of food that is as externally unappealing as the steamer clam. But steamed, rinsed in hot clam broth and then dunked in melted butter, there are few delights as visceral, gritty and real. Especially if you just dug them yourself. Since there were several of us digging, there were plenty of clams left over for a pot of chowder.
The woods in Maine are stunningly beautiful. Rocky, mossy, covered with ferns and shaded by thick groves of spruce and fir trees, hiking in the coastal forests in Maine really makes you feel transported, mentally as well as physically. This time, though, I must admit I was distracted by the enormous variety of mushrooms that were sprouting everywhere following recent rains (not to mention carrying a three-year-old, who in any case is trained to spot mushrooms). On every excursion into the forest we brought home gorgeous yellow chanterelle mushrooms for frittatas and the like, made with the first eggs from our spring chickens.
Blueberry season was petering out while we were there, but each walk we took yielded a handful or two of huckleberries, their later, taller cousins, and blackberries, which were in full swing. Not enough for a pie, but fortunately Dinah brought blueberries and apples from her Mom’s garden with her. We had the pleasure of sharing the house with two other pie professionals (what are the chances?) from Brooklyn, so we were treated to an endless stream of the best pies I’ve ever had, from classic lattice blueberry pie to apple galette and pear tart tatin.
Our host, Sara, has been summering in Isle au Haut ever since she was a girl. Growing up there, the summer people integrated with the native islanders in ways unthinkable in actual resort communities. So one evening, we got a bucket of fresh lobsters from Jason’s boat. Jason is a local lobsterman, but as a boy played softball with Sara (and everyone else in town) on summer evenings. We got to have a short visit with Jason for a window into the lobstering life. There are a lot of similarities with farming: repetitive work, subject to the weather and seasonal fluctuations, but on a boat on the water instead of on land.
Watching the lobster boats come and go on the thoroughfare is what passes for idle entertainment on Isle au Haut. Everybody knows everybody. First you hear their old pickups rumbling up to the town landing. (Many islanders can tell who’s coming just by the sound of their trucks.) A while later they row out to their boats, moor the rowboat, fire up the diesel and away they go to haul traps. About three quarters of the year-round population relies on lobster fishing for income.
Cooking lobster for eight with enough for leftovers was kind of a project. Luckily, the house was well-equipped and no doubt it was not the first time such feats were performed there. The Brooklyn pie shop girls were from South Dakota and lobster supper virgins. I explained that it’s a meal not unlike Thanksgiving in its seasonality and ritual. It’s convivial, better with more people, a ton of cleanup and you don’t need to eat it more than once a year.
And the leftovers are often the best eating. The next day Caroline baked a batch of light and puffy homemade rolls. Sara whipped up a delicious lobster salad with just a hint of mayo, shallot, celery and fresh tarragon from the farm. It was better than any lobster roll I’ve ever had.
In all my years of eating there has rarely been a week of food so rooted in nature, community and friends. It was a true gift of an experience, and a big thanks is in order to everyone (and every thing) who made it possible.